Welcome to Yardsale cafe
Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Yardsale Cafe offers a charming, unpretentious vibe reminiscent of a cozy yard sale. With an array of delectable baked goods, including their renowned cinnamon rolls and Nutella babka, this quaint spot delights with every bite. Reviewers rave about the ham and cheese croissant, dense with flavor, perfectly complementing their exceptional coffee. The café's interior, adorned with eclectic memorabilia for sale, creates a warm atmosphere perfect for a casual visit. Whether you’re indulging in a flaky delight or sipping an iced latte, Yardsale Cafe promises a memorable culinary experience worth returning for.
-
620 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States Hotline: +1 929-477-0167
Welcome to Yardsale Cafe, an eclectic gem tucked away at 620 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY. This cozy cafe captures the essence of a yard sale, uniquely combining a casual vibe with delectable baked goods that beckon food lovers from afar. With a phone number of +1 929-477-0167, it’s worth a call to check out their daily offerings.
As you step inside, you’re greeted by an array of charming memorabilia lining the walls—each piece lends a sense of nostalgia and personality, telling its own story. This unpretentious atmosphere makes for a perfect backdrop to enjoy your culinary explorations.
Now, let’s talk about the highlights! The Cinnamon Bun has garnered rave reviews for its decadent frosting and perfectly balanced cinnamon flavor. Customers like Rosalia Nolen have called it "the best I’ve had in my life," noting its croissant-like layers that melt in your mouth. And at just $7 for a generous serving, sharing this delightful treat is practically a must.
If you’re in the mood for something savory, the Ham and Cheese Croissant is a showstopper. Known for its generous filling, this croissant has been described as “not hollow,” but rather a satisfying meal in itself. The density and richness of the aged cheese paired with high-quality ham create a luxurious experience that pairs perfectly with a cold brew coffee.
Sweet tooth enthusiasts mustn’t miss the Nutella Babka. Renowned among locals, it has been described as "moist and decadent." The rich flavors of chocolate harmonize beautifully with the soft, pillowy dough, making it an indulgent treat for any time of day.
A visit to Yardsale Cafe is not just about great food—it’s about the experience. Customers like LIEM and Douglas Rennehan have highlighted the friendly vibe, the inviting atmosphere, and, of course, those irresistible baked goods like Cinnamon and Chocolate Babkas that are simply to die for. Whether you choose to savor your treats at the tiny window seat or enjoy the outdoor area, the cafe buzzes with a chill, laid-back ambiance that makes you want to stay a little longer.
In summary, Yardsale Cafe is more than just a cafe; it’s a sanctuary for food lovers seeking comfort and authenticity in every bite. Stop by to discover why it has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike—your taste buds will thank you!
Cute little cafe, that is exactly like a yard sale inside. I went in to try the cinnamon bun and omg it was soooo good. 1st- the frosting was ridiculously delicious, they put a nice healthy amount. The cinnamon level was perfect and the layers were less doughy but more croissant like with flaky layers. Wow it so good. The most expensive bun I’ve tried @7 but picked out the bigger piece of the remaining 2 and shared it and it was a perfect amount.
CASUAL CAFE WITH INCREDIBLE FOOD Yardsale Cafe feels exactly like how it sounds when you step inside. Unpretentious vibe made up of literal yard sale memorabilia on the walls that are for sale. The owner takes pride in what he bakes. The babka is well-known and delicious. So are the cookies. But what really hits it out of the park is the ham and cheese croissant It’s not the typical kind at other places that feel hollow and leaving you craving for more. No. These Ham and cheese croissants are densely packed with aged cheese ... it’s a meal that taps you out. Pairs well with cold brew. The space is very small with a tiny window seat inside and additional seating outside for that “back patio” feel. Super chill vibe here. Highly Recommend
The Nutella Babka and Cinnamon Roll are some of the best baked goods in New York City. Hands down. The Nutella Babka is so moist and decadent. The Cinnamon Roll is the best I’ve had in my life. It’s gigantic, gooey, and has the most delicious frosting. 10/10.
Unpretentious coffee spot with fabulous baked goods. Must try! We had an oatmeal iced latte, cheesecake and cinnamon babka. The cassettes on the wall a plus!
Great coffee, yummy cookies in a friendly cafe. Love the vintage items for sale. Bought some unique glasses and always leading through the records. The he babka is amazing.
After reading Google reviews with high ratings, I left home early and stopped by before going to work. It was around 7:30 shortly after the store opened, and I was impressed that all the products were lined up in the showcase. The calm and pleasant staff made a wonderful start to my day. Thank you. The ham and cheese croissant had a crispy skin and was filled with plenty of ham and cheese. The cheesecake was smooth and very delicious. Cinnamon Babka matches the sweetness of cinnamon and is perfect for coffee.
Not really a sit-down place because there are only two chairs, and in the morning the sun blasts you from the window, but this is very possibly the best ham and cheese croissant I've ever had! The staff were super friendly and the environment and atmosphere were very nice and clean and the cortado was excellent. I was visiting family because I live out of town but when I go back to Brooklyn I will absolutely be stopping by and trying the ridiculously rich looking Nutella babka!
I slept on this place for too long after moving to South Slope. This is my new favorite bakery! The atmosphere is great despite only having two seats, there is a lot for sale here on the walls (decor/records, etc). The cinnamon and chocolate babkas are to DIE FOR. I will be coming back here frequently to try all of their menu items, I’ve only been impressed so far. Also their ham and cheese croissants are just perfect after a night of drinking lol